Posted by Don Fullerton on Mar 23, 2012
Filed Under (Environmental Policy, Finance, U.S. Fiscal Policy)
Politicians like to say they want the U.S. to produce at least as much energy as it consumes – “energy independence”. And they certainly want to reassure consumers that they are doing something about the high price of gasoline. But the two goals are inconsistent. You can’t have both. Indeed, the current high price of oil is exactly what is now REDUCING our dependence on foreign oil!
We all know the price of gasoline has been increasing lately, now well over $4 per gallon in some locations. Five-dollar gas is predicted by Summer. In addition, the New York Times just reported that our dependence on foreign oil is falling. “In 2011, the country imported just 45 percent of the liquid fuels it used, down from a record high of 60 percent in 2005.” The article points out that this strong new trend is based BOTH on the increase of U.S. production of oil AND on the decreased U.S. consumption of it. And both of those factors are based on the recent increases in oil and gasoline prices. Those higher prices are enough to induce producers to revisit old oil wells and to use new more-expensive technology to extract more oil from those same wells. The higher prices also are enough to induce consumers to conserve. Purchases of large cars and SUVs are down. Many people are driving less, even in their existing cars. A different article on the same day’s New York Times, on the same front page, also reports that “many young consumers today just do not care that much about cars.”
Decreased dependence on foreign oil does sound like good news. Actually, it is good for a number of reasons. (1) It is good for business in oil-producing states, helping raise them out of the current economic slow-growth period. (2) It is good for national energy security, not to have to depend on unstable governments around the rest of the world. (3) It reduces the overall U.S. trade deficit, of which the net import of oil was a big component. And (4) the reduced consumption of gasoline is good for the environment.
On the other hand, the increased U.S. production of oil is not good for the environment, as discussed in the same newspaper article just mentioned. As an aside, I would prefer to do more to decrease U.S. consumption of oil – not only from increased fuel efficiency but also by the use of alternative non-fossil fuels – and perhaps less from increased U.S. production of oil from dirty sources such as shale or tar sands. But that’s not the point for the moment.
The point for the moment is just that maybe the higher price of gasoline is a GOOD thing! We can’t take even small steps toward decreasing U.S. dependence on foreign oil UNLESS oil and gas prices rise. Any politician who tells you otherwise is pandering for your vote. It is the high price of oil that is both increasing U.S. production and decreasing U.S. Consumption.